Tuesday, March 20, 2012
Former postdoc Sophia Engel got new job
Sunday, March 18, 2012
On density-dependent diversification and speciation in birds
This coming Wednesday (March 21 at 13.30 NOTE TIME!!!!), we will discuss a paper about the (possible) density-dependent slowdown of cladogenesis in birds with the progress of adaptive radiation. It is a paper that was published relatively recently, although it is not entirely new, in PLoS Biology by Albert Phillimore and Trevor D. Price. The title of the paper is:
"Density-Dependent Cladogenesis in Birds"
The authors have used molecular phylogenies from various avian groups to test the hypothesis that diversification rates decline with the progress of adaptive radiation, and as we are approaching the present. Here is the Abstract to the article, which can be downloaded here (PLoS Biology is a "Open Acess"-publisher, which makes everything easier):
Abstract
Saturday, March 3, 2012
Lab meeting March 7: challenges and prospects of quantitative trait studies
Tuesday, February 28, 2012
reporting from the Animal Behaviour graduate course
But first, let’s go back in time about 6 months, when Ben and I went down to gorgeous Portugal to learn new skills at the First IV workshop led by Diane Ebert-May. Here we heard about and learned to put into practice techniques for student-centered learning. I wrote about that in a previous blog. With this in mind, we designed last week’s course, and we have a feeling that we were successful, more on that below.
To remind you, with student centered learning, the students are actively involved in their own learning: students are thinking about the concepts, research questions and discuss these with other students and teachers. This means that we worked hard to provide the opportunity for the students to be active during the classes. Some of the telltale sings of our approach working can be seen in these pictures below.
Apart from us practicing our teaching techniques, we covered a large area of topics, and invited in-house and external experts to the course to provide the students with the view from scientists at the front of their field. These in-house experts were: Michi Tobler & Caroline Isaksson (physiology and behavior), Mathias Osvath (animal cognition), Charlie Cornwallis (sexual selection). We also invited three workshop leaders from outside Lund. These were Dan Franks (university of York), who inspired us to think about social networks in biology and how to analyse them. Niels Dingemanse (Max Planck institute for Ornithology) who has developed methods to analyse animal personality data. Hans Slabbekoorn (Leiden University) led a workshop on acoustic analysis and told us about environmental influences (anthropogenic or natural) on animal communication.
Each of them gave inspiring contributions, and the students, including Ben and I, learned many new things and were inspired to think about our own research from a bunch of new angles.
Thus, from our perspective the course was a success. All Ph.D students completed the course, the content and teaching styles were diverse and the students were actively engaged in their own learning. The anonymous student feedback was also positive. The mean overall course score was 3.94 in a scale between 1 – 5 where 4 = Excellent! Interesting and covered all relevant information. Students scored the overall difficulty of the course at 3.13, where 3 = The right level of difficulty. We also asked students anonymously in the evaluation whether they would recommend this course to a colleague. 100% of respondents replied ‘Yes’. Our aim was to teach the course in an active learning style (see Handelsman et al. 2004, Science), and we encouraged all contributors to involve discussions and student-centred learning techniques where possible. This style received very positive feedback from students: In response to the two questions “Comments generally about the course/What did you like about the course?” 14/16 completed feedback forms spontaneously praised the interactive approach and our use of discussion within classes to facilitate learning. Students were very positive about the opportunity to interact socially with one another and also the visiting lecturers, and enjoyed the research talks. The highest feedback score was for the ‘speed dating activity’ where students had 2 minutes in pairs to come up with an interesting collaboration. After the 2 minutes had passed students switched to a new partner and designed a new collaboration. This allowed everyone to apply their creative skills to generate new and exciting research questions and worked very well.
Critical feedback from the students
We also received important feedback on how we could improve the course should it run a second time. Many students found the data analysis workshops too intense and difficult, which is reflected in their lower mean scores (~3/5) compared to the more general classes. There were also requests for more examples from the invertebrate literature. Both of these issues raised could easily be addressed; in the first case by modifying the workshops to make them more inclusive and less software oriented; in the second case we could include a contributor working with an invertebrate system.
We also received positive feedback from the staff and visiting speakers involved in the course.
Ben and I would like to thank all the collaborators, in-house and external, for working so hard with us to make this course a success. The effort clearly paid off!
Below the statistics on the feedback:
Scoring: 5 = This was the best hour and a half of my waking life; 4 = Excellent! Interesting and covered all relevant information; 3 = Good, but could be improved; 2 = Not so inspiring; 1 = An effective substitute for water boarding
Saturday, February 25, 2012
Lab meeting Feb 29: genetic basis of adaptation
For the next EXEB lab meeting (Wednesday February 29), I suggest we read a recent paper from Evolution about the genetic basis of adaptation.
Rockman, M. V. 2012. The QTN program and the alleles that matter for evolution: all that's gold does not glitter. Evolution 66(1):1-17.
Abstract: The search for the alleles that matter, the quantitative trait nucleotides (QTNs) that underlie heritable variation within populations and divergence among them, is a popular pursuit. But what is the question to which QTNs are the answer? Although their pursuit is often invoked as a means of addressing the molecular basis of phenotypic evolution or of estimating the roles of evolutionary forces, the QTNs that are accessible to experimentalists, QTNs of relatively large effect, may be uninformative about these issues if large-effect variants are unrepresentative of the alleles that matter. Although 20th century evolutionary biology generally viewed large-effect variants as atypical, the field has recently undergone a quiet realignment toward a view of readily discoverable large-effect alleles as the primary molecular substrates for evolution. I argue that neither theory nor data justify this realignment. Models and experimental findings covering broad swaths of evolutionary phenomena suggest that evolution often acts via large numbers of small-effect polygenes, individually undetectable. Moreover, these small-effect variants are different in kind, at the molecular level, from the large-effect alleles accessible to experimentalists. Although discoverable QTNs address some fundamental evolutionary questions, they are essentially misleading about many others.
We'll start at 13.00 in Argumentet.
Saturday, February 18, 2012
New blog name and a few words about the past and the future
By that time, our department was (and still largely is), very dominated by bird behavioural ecology and two large research groups: Molecular Ecology and Bird Migration Ecology. It was therefore a bit odd to try to start up something in between these two large groups, that was neither, and in this case an evolutionary and ecological research programme focussed on field studies on insects and with a strong connection to quantitative genetics and selection approaches. Moreover, at that time (unlike today), odonates were still considered to be quite odd study organisms, both in Lund and elsewhere. It was quite lonely, at times, to strive to cut out an independent niche in a department so strongly focussed on birds and behavioural ecology, and it was tempting several times to give up, and just follow the crowd along some easier path.
Luckily, I got several excellent PhD-students, who were all succesful in terms of their theses, defended, got postdocs and went abroad to learn new things: Jessica Abbott in 2006, Tom Gosden in 2008, Fabrice Eroukhanoff in 2009 and Kristina Karlsson in 2010. Of these former PhD-students, Jessica recently obtained a "Junior Project Grant" from "Vetenskapsrådet" last year, and as you know she has now re-established herself in Lund and in our research environment. She is hopefully not the last of my current and former PhD-students/postdocs who will be able to establish herself as an independent PI, but only the future will tell this, of course. This spring several of you will apply from VR, and later this year, Tom Gosden will return to Lund from Australia on a one-year postdoc (Marie Curie). Any new PhD-students entering this group will have an idéal situation in the form of several postdoctoral mentors, good role models and senior scientists.
Given these happy and exciting developments, I feel that the goal I did put up more than a decade ago, i. e. to build up a new evolutionary oriented research group in Lund focussing on insects/invertebrates, has largely been achieved. As there is now more than one senior scientist and PI, it is time for me to transform this group in to more of a collective enterprise, and less of a one-man show. This has already started to happen, naturally, as lab-meetings were obviously running when I was recently away in South Africa. This is great, and exactly how I want it to be. A research group cannot stand and fall with a single person, it has to be a collective effort.
Time is therefore mature to change the name of both the blog and the research group. These new changes will soon be seen also at the the department's website. I strongly feel that it is important to have a group of people who regularly meet, as several brains work synergistically, and intellectual lab-meetings of the kind we have had over the years should be the last thing to prioritize down, even if time is always limited. As for myself, I will now try to cut down on the number of projects, focus more on my own research and hopefully share some of the administrative burden and advising activities with Jessica and those others of you who might also hopefully soon enter as new PI:s.
A few more words about the new name of the blog, which I and Jessica have discussed before deciding on EXEB. "Experimental Evolution", i. e. the first two words, signify the important fact that Jessica brings with her an entirely new research approach to Lund and our research group, while at the same time we keep our strong focus on ecology and behaviour.
Some might argue that there are other groups in our department working with these topics too, and that our research group is therefore obsolete or unnecessary. Perhaps we should simply dissolve it, and happily integrate ourselves with other similar groups like MEEL, The PEG ("theoretical ecology") or "Bird Migration Ecology"?. Well, I do not think so, otherwise I would of course have shut down this blog a long time ago. Personally, I think we represent a significant and different research current than these other groups, without denying that they also do good work.
There is clearly room for a research group that is both integrative (i. e. combines molecular, experimental and field approaches) and theoretically oriented (although not a pure theory group), and which is firmly rooted in population and evolutionary quantitative genetics. That is who we are and what we are good at, I think. And we also have a certain responsibility to represent this particular research tradition in Lund, rather than trying to copy others and become too similar to other research groups.
Finally: Goodbye "Erik Svensson Research Laboratory" and long live EXEB!
New Drossie paper, multivariate genetic constraints on sexual dimorphism
A quick post from down under highlighting a new paper that has just gone "online early" at Evolution. It contains work I have been doing with Steve Chenoweth on the Australian vinegar fly, Drosophila serrata (see picture above). In the paper we attempt to quantify the degree of constraint imposed on sexually homologous traits by the between-sex covariance matrix, B, first introduced in a seminal paper by Lande in 1980. For those not familiar with quantitative genetics it is a little heavy in places, but I hope that you will all find it relatively easy to read and enjoyable none-the-less. For any of you who can't get to it behind the paywall, please feel free to e-mail me and I'll be happy to send you a copy.